Skip to main content

Table 5 Failure criteria in literature for concrete in LS-DYNA (Hallquist 2006).

From: Effect of Alkali-Silica Reactivity Damage to Tip-Over Impact Performance of Dry Cask Storage Structures

Problems

Materials

Criteria

Limits

Mesh sizes (mm)

References

Impact

Concrete 27.5 MPa

Principal strain

0.003

80 × 80 × 60

Huang and Wu (2009)

Blast

Concrete 40 MPa

Principal strain

0.01

18.75 × 18.75 × 25

Xu and Lu (2006)

Blast

Concrete 24 MPa

Principal strain

0.15

50

Shi et al. (2010)

Blast

Concrete 24 MPa

Shear strain

0.9

50

Shi et al. (2010)

Blast

Concrete 60 MPa

Tensile strain

5 MPa

6.25–100

Tang and Hao (2010)

Blast

Concrete 60 MPa

Principal strain

0.1

6.25–100

Tang and Hao (2010)

Blast

Concrete 40 MPa

Maximum strain

0.1

50

Wu et al. (2011)

Blast

FRC 1% 28 MPa

Shear strain

0.4

 

Wang et al. (2009)

Blast

FRC 1% 28 MPa

Tensile stress

5.4 MPa

 

Wang et al. (2009)

Blast

FRC 1.5% 30 MPa

Shear strain

0.4

 

Wang et al. (2010)

Blast

FRC 1.5% 30 MPa

Tensile stress

6 MPa

 

Wang et al. (2010)

Blast

FRC 2% 32 MPa

Shear strain

0.4

 

Wang et al. (2010)

Blast

FRC 2% 32 MPa

Tensile stress

7.5 MPa

 

Wang et al. (2010)

Blast

FRC 45 MPa

Damage

0.99

25 × 25

Coughlin et al. (2010)

Dynamic

Concrete 35 MPa

Principal strain

0.002

6–8

Tu and Lu (2010)

Impact

Concrete 40 MPa

Strain limit

1.5

 

Tu and Lu (2010)

Impact

Concrete 48–140 MPa

Strain failure

−1 (Comp)

0.5 (Tens)

2

Islam et al. (2011)

Impact

FRC 28–32 MPa

Tension stress failure

5.4 MPa

1.25

Teng et al. (2003)

Impact

FRC 28–32 MPa

Shear strain

0.4

1.25

Teng et al. (2003)

Impact

HPFRC

Ultimate shear strain

0.012

6 × 8

Farnam et al. (2010)