Specimen no. | Control—non forced direction | CFRP—non forced direction | Fe-SMA—non forced direction | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
5Â cm | 15Â cm | 20Â cm | 5Â cm | 15Â cm | 20Â cm | 5Â cm | 15Â cm | 20Â cm | ||
Before loading | 1 | 4199 | 4163 | 4190 | 4337 | 4441 | 4178 | 4343 | 4087 | 4108 |
2 | 4288 | 4155 | 4118 | 4383 | 4205 | 4237 | 4305 | 4116 | 4043 | |
3 | 4246 | 4097 | 4173 | 4344 | 4231 | 4234 | 4330 | 4181 | 4097 | |
Avg | 4244 | 4138 | 4160 | 4355 | 4292 | 4217 | 4326 | 4128 | 4082 | |
Cycle 1 | 1 | 4234 | 4151 | 4064 | – | – | – | – | – | – |
2 | 4275 | 4120 | 4160 | – | – | – | – | – | – | |
3 | 4259 | 4107 | 4098 | – | – | – | – | – | – | |
Avg | 4256 | 4126 | 4107 | – | – | – | – | – | – | |
Cycle 2 | 1 | 4277 | 4071 | 4127 | 4199 | 4053 | 4114 | 4167 | 4027 | 4074 |
2 | 4307 | 4127 | 4159 | 4235 | 4096 | 4068 | 4191 | 4089 | 4025 | |
3 | 4285 | 4151 | 4138 | 4226 | 4052 | 4092 | 4189 | 4004 | 4063 | |
Avg | 4289 | 4116 | 4141 | 4220 | 4067 | 4091 | 4182 | 4040 | 4054 | |
Cycle 3 | 1 | 4233 | 4036 | 4111 | – | – | – | – | – | – |
2 | 4244 | 4121 | 4123 | – | – | – | – | – | – | |
3 | 4203 | 4135 | 4055 | – | – | – | – | – | – | |
Avg | 4226 | 4097 | 4096 | – | – | – | – | – | – | |
Cycle 4 | 1 | 4274 | 4106 | 4061 | 4164 | 3982 | 4023 | 4164 | 4019 | 4055 |
2 | 4267 | 4087 | 4022 | 4229 | 3898 | 4024 | 4152 | 4038 | 4087 | |
3 | 4182 | 4074 | 4019 | 4106 | 3975 | 4041 | 4151 | 4055 | 4271 | |
Avg | 4241 | 4089 | 4034 | 4166 | 3951 | 4029 | 4155 | 4037 | 4137 | |
Cycle 6 | 1 | 3612 | 2651 | 3304 | 3612 | 3726 | 3939 | 3675 | 3730 | 3978 |
2 | 3645 | 2651 | 3329 | 3618 | 3796 | 3886 | 3656 | 3332 | 4022 | |
3 | – | 2959 | – | 3594 | 3726 | 3938 | 3755 | 3457 | 3991 | |
Avg | 3628 | 2753 | 3316 | 3608 | 3749 | 3921 | 3695 | 3506 | 4003 | |
Cycle 7 | 1 | – | – | – | 3499 | 3440 | 3781 | 4026 | 3654 | 3966 |
2 | – | – | – | 3495 | 3475 | 3741 | 3699 | 3665 | 3980 | |
3 | – | – | – | 3494 | 3523 | 3689 | 3709 | 3644 | 3968 | |
Avg | – | – | – | 3496 | 3479 | 3737 | 3811 | 3654 | 3971 | |
Cycle 8 | 1 | – | – | – | 3276 | 3358 | 3522 | 3553 | 3515 | 3945 |
2 | – | – | – | 3289 | 3367 | 3530 | 3543 | 3541 | 4083 | |
3 | – | – | – | 3315 | 3324 | 3534 | 3787 | 3533 | 3941 | |
Avg | – | – | – | 3293 | 3349 | 3528 | 3627 | 3529 | 3989 | |
Cycle 9 | 1 | – | – | – | 3262 | 3267 | 3451 | 3484 | 3467 | 3849 |
2 | – | – | – | 6148 | 3382 | 3443 | 3495 | 3417 | 3836 | |
3 | – | – | – | 3333 | 3231 | 3464 | 3439 | 3350 | 3857 | |
Avg | – | – | – | 3247 | 3293 | 3452 | 3472 | 3411 | 3847 | |
Cycle 10 | 1 | – | – | – | 3055 | 3224 | 3350 | 3159 | 3409 | 3776 |
2 | – | – | – | 3051 | 3281 | 3385 | 3208 | 3393 | 3765 | |
3 | – | – | – | 3077 | 3151 | 3406 | 3234 | 3395 | 3762 | |
Avg | – | – | – | 3061 | 3218 | 3380 | 3200 | 3399 | 3767 |