Table 6 Comparison of compression test results from each insulation system
a) FIRECOAT | b) REALROCK | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Specimen | Max. Load (N) | Max. Stress (N/mm2) | Specimen | Max. Load (N) | Max. Stress (N/mm2) | ||||
ID | No | ID | No | ||||||
Ref. | Ref | 1 | 945281.56 | 30.09 | Ref. | Ref | 1 | 945281.56 | 30.09 |
Ref-30 | 6 | 560723.19 | 17.85 | Ref-30 | 5 | 543543.69 | 17.30 | ||
Ref-60 | 4 | 536824.31 | 17.09 | Ref-60 | 3 | 536824.31 | 17.09 | ||
Set-1 | CFRP | 7 | 2705007.00 | 86.10 | Set-1 | CFRP | 7 | 2705007.00 | 86.10 |
CFRP-30 | 12 | 1088490.13 | 34.65 | CFRP-30 | 11 | 1249386.13 | 39.77 | ||
CFRP-60 | 10 | 576904.00 | 18.36 | CFRP-60 | 9 | 576904.00 | 18.36 | ||
CFRP-T1-30 | 20 | 1137223.13 | 36.20 | CFRP-T1-30 | 15 | 2167975.00 | 69.01 | ||
CFRP-T1-60 | 18 | 587583.44 | 18.70 | CFRP-T1-60 | 13 | 599746.44 | 19.09 | ||
CFRP-T2-30 | 24 | 2371450.25 | 75.49 | CFRP-T2-30 | 19 | 2235780.75 | 71.17 | ||
CFRP-T2-60 | 22 | – | – | CFRP-T2-60 | 17 | – | – | ||
Set-2 | GFRP | 25 | 2143591.00 | 68.23 | CFRP-T3-30 | 23 | 2338961.50 | 74.45 | |
GFRP-30 | 30 | 734890.63 | 23.39 | CFRP-T3-60 | 21 | 1676887.50 | 53.38 | ||
GFRP-60 | 28 | 603850.81 | 19.22 | Set-2 | GFRP | 25 | 2143591.00 | 68.23 | |
GFRP-T1-30 | 38 | 972557.44 | 30.96 | GFRP-30 | 29 | 796519.69 | 25.35 | ||
GFRP-T1-60 | 36 | 675841.88 | 21.51 | GFRP-60 | 27 | 661006.13 | 21.04 | ||
GFRP-T2-30 | 42 | 1636213.25 | 52.08 | GFRP-T1-30 | 33 | 1408400.38 | 44.83 | ||
GFRP-T2-60 | 40 | 440795.81 | 14.03* | GFRP-T1-60 | 31 | 769538.19 | 24.50 | ||
GFRP-T2-30 | 37 | 1866427.63 | 59.41 | ||||||
GFRP-T2-60 | 35 | 1416181.88 | 45.08 | ||||||
GFRP-T3-30 | 41 | 2040831.63 | 64.96 | ||||||
GFRP-T3-60 | 39 | 1607563.50 | 51.17 | ||||||